My Honest Misfits Market Review: The Ultimate Guide

By Finders & Keep
📅 February 22, 2024

If you’re like me, you’re always looking for ways to save time and money, especially in the kitchen. I do like to cook, but between work and my family, I don’t always have time to shop or plan meals. So, I set out to find a food solution that would be convenient, affordable, and delicious all at the same time. I’ve tried a few different meal service boxes so far; I even tried Misfits Market when it first launched, but back then, I wasn’t a fan. Now, I’ve changed my mind — so what’s different the second time around? My Misfits Market review explains everything you need to know about this food delivery service.

For most meal services, I’ve found that the ingredient variety was limited and the cost was too high for what you get. Admittedly, I felt the same way about Misfits Market when I first tried it. Some of my items got substituted for things that I didn’t know how to cook (what the heck do you make with persimmons?) and felt like I couldn’t really customize my box to my preferences.

Recently, however, Misfits Market sent me a “we want you back” email explaining that they had totally revamped their grocery delivery box. Now, rather than sending a random box of vegetables, Misfits Market would allow me to build my order with a variety of food products that I actually wanted, including fresh produce, fruits, grains, herbs, and even pantry items like chocolate and peanut butter — the items you’d find at your local supermarket, and then some.

So, I decided to give Misfits Market another try to see if I liked their new system better.

In a rush? Get the fast facts: 

  • My honest Misfits Market review changed with new features
  • Customize everything in your box
  • Save up to 30% on groceries
  • Get organic produce, pantry items, meat, and even wine
  • Reasonable prices thanks to excess supply and “ugly produce” 
  • Schedule deliveries whenever
  • Ships to your door in sustainable packaging
  • Use code FINDANDKEEP15 for $15 off your first order (when you spend $35 or more)

Build Your Box With Food You Actually Want
Misfits Market

I customized my box with tons of yummy produce and even added a few pantry items with their popular new products. The service has expanded its offerings to include essentials like wine, meat, protein alternatives, dairy alternatives, and dairy products, which makes all the difference. In short, the brand provides a full grocery service for those who might not live in a neighborhood with quick access to healthy, affordable ingredients.

My Misfits Market box shipped right to my doorstep. The whole process was quick and easy. But I’m sure you’re mostly here to hear about what was inside my box, so let’s get to it. (Spoiler alert: I was extremely impressed this time around.)

My Misfits Market Review — The Second Time Around

Convenience is key in most things I do, which is why a meal or grocery delivery service was so appealing to me in the first place. If I can order my groceries for the week between meetings and throwing in a load of laundry, I call it a win! So, Misfits gets a thumbs up in that area from me.

I love that I can build a Misfits Market order anytime, day or night. You create an account, they autofill your cart with best-selling products they think you’ll love or have purchased before. Of course, you can customize, pause, or skip your order. You can also change your delivery or shop now for the soonest delivery if you forgot items or need more groceries outside of your scheduled shipments. 

Organic Produce For Less
Misfits Market

Fresh, Organic Produce For Less

One of my fears with food delivery boxes is always that the food will be spoiled or expired by the time it gets to me. Let me tell you, that was not the case with my Misfits Market box. Everything was fresh and might I add, delicious.

Did you know that oftentimes, the products you find in the grocery stores have traveled great distances from the farm to your local grocery store? Misfits Market delivers fresh produce in every box. They partner with local and regional farmers in your area to cut out the middleman and reduce the amount of time it takes to get your produce from the field to your plate. That way, the produce can be picked ripe and you get the freshest items possible. The majority of items are organic, which means free of synthetic fertilizers, pesticides, and GMOs, so you’re getting nothing but nutrient-rich food.

While we’re on the subject of fresh, I have to shout out the tomatoes from my last box. While they were a bit smaller than what I used to buy at the grocery store, they tasted amazing! They were ripe, plump, and juicy – the perfect tomatoes for my BLT. 

If you’re also buying the bacon and bread from this service, you can rest assured that it’s top quality and available at the most competitive price possible. I love Dave’s Killer Bread and Niman Ranch pork. Along with sustainably sourced fruits and vegetables, the pantry items are chosen with just as much care. For instance, their oat milk from Minor Figures is a carbon-neutral product.

Finally, to save even more, you can use code FINDANDKEEP15 for $15 off your first order when you spend $35 or more. (This offer is valid for first-time purchasers only, must be claimed by November 30, 2023 at 11:45 PM ET, and must be used in full by December 31, 2023 at 11:45 PM ET. Maximum discount of $15 applied at checkout towards your first order. Order minimum applies, and $35 order minimum required to redeem offer. Offer not valid for past purchases and may not be combined with other offers. Exclusions may apply.) 

Grocery Items In Bulk

Another reason I’m thrilled with the new Misfits Market grocery program: I can order my favorite discounted grocery items in bulk. I purchased 15 loaves of Cobblestone bread (the take-and-bake kind) at a discounted rate (that may sound excessive, but have you tried this bread?). I put 12 loaves in my freezer so I can pull them out and thaw them as we need them. Why did I buy 15 loaves? My whole family loves this bread, but it’s kind of pricey at our local health food store. I added it to my Misfits Market box and got it for 30% less than I normally pay. 

Along with essentials like eggs, dairy, and bread, they’ve got tons of discounted pantry items available like peanut butter, pasta, nuts, and sweets, too. Sometimes (read: most times), I even indulge and order organic dark chocolate or Lily’s peanut butter cups. Many of these brands are ethical and sustainable, so you can purchase them without guilt.

Meal Planning Just Got Easier

I was already feeling pretty good about giving Misfits Market another chance (and clearly it was a hit), but when I saw the recipes section it sent me over the edge. This takes the grocery subscription box to the next level. 

Misfits Market also has a blog where they share hundreds of recipes for their food items. There’s something for everyone, from pasta dishes to salads to desserts. Plus, Chef Bobby Flay works with them on many of their recipes, so using their recipes is also teaching me tips and tricks about cooking in general.

This feature makes it so much easier to meal plan. When it’s time to build my box, I just browse through their recipes (created by a renowned Chef!), add the necessary items, and in less than 30 minutes, I have made my menus for the week and purchased the ingredients I need. And if I’m tight on time, I build a box with staples that I know the family loves and search for recipes in their blog once the items arrive.

With so many options as an online grocery service, there’s nothing you can’t find.

Chef-Created Recipes & Meal Ideas
Misfits Market

What Is Ugly Produce?

I knew that Misfits Market advertises their “ugly produce,” but I have to say I was disappointed when I opened that initial box. In my head, I would open my box to a giant mutant zucchini with two heads and a heart-shaped pepper, but other than some slightly small (but extremely juicy) tomatoes, nothing was abnormal.

The produce that is misshapen or “ugly” comes that way because they’re arriving straight from the farm to your door. These produce items are 100% organic and aren’t treated with harsh chemicals that make supermarket produce look so perfect and uniform. They’re equally (if not more) delicious as what you can shop in the grocery store, plus they’re chemical-free and no food, ugly or not, goes to waste.

The truth is, many of these “ugly” veggies look completely normal, and combined with their other dry goods and pantry essentials, you can make a luxurious five-star meal for a reasonable cost. 

More Than Just A Produce Delivery Service

Although they first became famous for their produce, Misfits Market is so much more than just a source of fruit and veggies. They also have wine, high-quality proteins, and other ingredients to fill your pantry. Misfits has expanded to include an impressive and large catalog of highly desired items, making it a one-stop shop for all of your grocery needs.

There are three separate categories you can shop:  Food (produce and pantry items), wine, and cold items (including meats and dairy). 

& You Can Order Wine Online

It’s helpful to know that this service can make meal planning way easier, but the fact that they now offer wine means that you no longer have to wait in a long line at the liquor store or supermarket to get your Cabernet or Merlot on. 

You can choose between high-end wines that may be organic, use sustainable practices, are vegan, or are low-sulfite. They then sell curated bundles which help to highlight and enhance flavors in your selected wine. I mean, since when is one bottle enough? 

While they don’t sell individual bottles, the bundles are sold in packs of three, which helps to deliver in a sustainable way while providing you the biggest savings possible.  

The result is just as affordable as your local store and way tastier.

High-End Wine For Less
Misfits Market

How is Misfits Market Different From Grocery Stores?

Finding tasty organic food is one thing, but knowing your food arrived in a sustainable way is just as important! Most of their produce is non-GMO and organic, and they even offer a transparent list of the ingredients they’re currently selling and information on where they came from. 

You might be wondering: how exactly can they charge such low prices for high-quality groceries? Because they offer direct access to excess supply and “ugly” fruits and veggies. Anywhere else, you’d pay a premium, but by cutting out the middleman, Misfits Market products become extraordinarily affordable. 

Other Misfits Market Reviews

Depending on where you look, other Misfits Market reviews are mixed. For example, on TrustPilot, customers have complained about some unexpected automatic deliveries — so if you do sign up, be sure to change (and keep an eye on) your shipment details so they suit your needs. 

Once they got the hang of the service, however, reviewers had incredible things to say about Misfits Market: “Loving these boxes so far. Shopping for what I want or don’t want, the produce is great quality and fresh. Saves me a ton of money and I’m eating healthier,” wrote one TrustPilot reviewer. Another customer from the website raved, “I’m uber impressed at the quality of the organic produce. Saved me a lot of time and energy this week, aaaaand I saved some $$$. No membership fees. They have a lot more than just produce.”

Finally, Insider called it “convenient to use” and “reasonably priced,” while Food & Wine said “none of [the produce] compromised on quality and taste.” 

So, What Is My Honest Misfits Market Review?

I will admit, I was on the fence when I tried Misfits Market a few years ago. There wasn’t anything wrong with what they sent me, per se — I just wasn’t overly impressed. With the substituted items, meal planning was hard and I often got ingredients I didn’t use. 

With the new Misfits Market program, however, I get to pick exactly what I want and there are no more substitutions. I only get what I order. Plus, since I first tried it, this service has grown rapidly, serving all of the lower 48 states and expanding into an online grocery service with an impressive variety of products. Who knows what they’ll offer next?

Now, I can plan and shop in just minutes. The produce is fresh, organic, and costs less than what I’d pay at the grocery store. I love that I can stock up on other grocery items, too (at Misfits Market’s discounted prices), making weekly grocery shopping more convenient and accessible. Unlike in-person stores, you always know what’s going to be in stock, and you can order from the comfort of your own home while reducing food waste at the same time. Most importantly, products are up to 40% off, and given the current prices of coffee, tea, and alcoholic beverages, that’s a huge win. 

Furthermore, it’s suitable for all kinds of diets, including keto, paleo, omnivores, pescatarians, vegetarians, and vegans thanks to its wide selection of products. That means that you can buy cheap, organic food for the entire family here, even if everyone has a different diet.  With the added benefit of it being delivered straight to your door, you can free up your time for some much-needed self-care, like I was able to.

Basically, my Misfits Market review: I really appreciate the ease, convenience, and affordability, and I’m glad that I gave them another try — because now I’m hooked. 

Interested? Shop Misfits Market Here.

Thanks for reading this Misfits Market review! We strive to provide you with honest feedback about the products we use and love. So you’re aware, this is a sponsored post and we may collect a commission from the affiliate links on this page, which help us keep Finders & Keep up and running. Product prices are correct at the time of publication but may be subject to change.

Subscribe to our newsletter
for editor picks and exclusive deals

Finders & Keep has an advertising relationship with some of the brands discussed on this site and we may receive a referral fee when someone clicks on one of our affiliate partner links. 

The opinions expressed on Finders & Keep are entirely our own. The content was chosen by our editorial team. Any product claim or representation about a product or service should be verified with the manufacturer or provider.